Search for the best donation platform and you get lists with twenty names, each one “the best”. The trouble is that a platform that suits a national charity running galas can be wrong for a youth club with one volunteer and a Wix site. The right choice depends on a handful of decisions about how you want people to give.
This guide walks through those decisions in the order they matter, shows what a $50 gift actually leaves you on the most popular platforms, and ends with a short checklist you can use on any shortlist. When you are ready to put a form on your site, follow the online donation form setup guide.
Start with where the gift happens
Every donation platform makes one big choice for you: whether donors give on your website or on the platform’s own page. It shapes everything after it.
- On your own site. A donation box sits inside your pages. Donors never leave the story that moved them, your brand stays in front of them, and every visit you earn from search, email and social ends in a gift on your domain.
- On a platform page. You get a hosted page on the platform’s domain. It is quick to launch and some platforms add their own audience of browsing donors, but the visitor leaves your site at the exact moment they decide to give.
GivePilot is built around the first model. The donation box, a donate button that follows visitors across every page, and campaign boxes with a live goal all run inside your Wix, Shopify or any other website. If your site already brings people in, keeping the gift there is usually the single biggest improvement you can make.
Work out what each gift really costs
There are three ways donation platforms earn money, and most use one of them:
- A percentage of each gift on top of card processing. Easy to start, and it grows as you raise more.
- Optional donor tips requested at checkout, which fund a free platform.
- A flat subscription, with nothing taken from the gift itself beyond your payment provider’s processing fee.
Here is what a $50 card gift leaves you in the US on some well-known platforms, using each company’s own published rates.
| Platform | Platform fee on the gift | Processing on a $50 card gift | What reaches you |
|---|---|---|---|
| GivePilot with Stripe | None | $1.75 (Stripe’s standard US card rate, 2.9% + 30¢) | $48.25 |
| GivePilot with PayPal | None | $1.49 (PayPal’s published charity rate, 1.99% + 49¢) | $48.51 |
| GoFundMe, certified nonprofit | None | $1.40 (2.2% + 30¢) | $48.60 |
| Donorbox Standard | $1.48 (2.95%) | $1.40 (Stripe nonprofit rate, 2.2% + 30¢) | $47.12 |
| Givebutter, tips turned off | $1.50 (3%) | $1.75 (2.9% + 30¢) | $46.75 |
| Givebutter, tips turned on | None | Covered by donor or Givebutter | $50.00 |
| Zeffy | None | Covered by Zeffy | $50.00 |
US figures from each company’s pricing page on November 13, 2026. GivePilot’s paid plans add a flat $8.99 or $17.99 a month and Donorbox’s paid plans add a subscription; Givebutter and Zeffy ask donors for an optional tip at checkout.
Percentages look small on one gift and large over a year. On $40,000 of online gifts, a 3% platform fee is $1,200 that never reaches your programs. A flat plan stays the same whether you raise $4,000 or $400,000.
Make sure donors can give monthly
Monthly donors are the steadiest income a small organization can build. Look for three things:
- A one-time or monthly choice right in the donation box, with no separate form.
- An automatic receipt for every renewal, so donors always have a record.
- A way for donors to manage or cancel on their own, which keeps your inbox clear and builds trust.
In GivePilot, monthly giving runs through Stripe on the Grassroot plan. Every renewal sends its own receipt, and donors sign in to a donor portal with a one-time email code to see their history or cancel. Nobody has to remember a password.
Check the payment options
Donors abandon a gift when their preferred way to pay is missing. Card is essential, PayPal is a strong second, and if you already take payments in person with Square it helps to keep everything in one account.
GivePilot connects to Stripe, PayPal and Square, and you can connect all three. The money goes straight into your own accounts, never through a middle account, so payouts follow the schedule you already have with your provider.
Look at the receipts and the thank-you
A donor’s first impression after giving is the receipt. It should arrive instantly, carry your organization’s name, and let the donor reply to a real person. GivePilot sends one receipt per donation the moment it succeeds, with replies going to the inbox you choose, and on the Grassroot plan it can send from your own email address.
Count the setup time
The best donation platform is the one you can have working this afternoon. With GivePilot, setup asks one question per screen: your organization’s name, where replies should go, your currency, your amounts and colour. It then connects a payment provider and hands you the code for your site, with your real donation box updating beside you as you answer. On Wix and Shopify you add the box from the editor instead of pasting code.
A checklist for any shortlist
- Can donors give without leaving my website?
- What does a $50 gift leave me after every fee, and what do I pay per month?
- Can donors choose monthly in the same box, and can they cancel themselves?
- Which payment providers can I connect, and does the money land in my own account?
- Does every gift send a receipt in my organization’s name?
- Does it work on the website builder I already use?
- Can I run a campaign with a goal, a deadline and updates?
