The best nonprofit donation platforms by what you actually keep

Fees decide how much of every gift reaches your mission. We compare the best nonprofit donation platforms on a $50 gift and over a year of giving.

November 13, 2026Updated November 17, 20268 min readBy the GivePilot team

Two donation platforms can look identical on screen and leave you with very different amounts at the end of the year. The difference is in how each one charges. This guide compares the best nonprofit donation platforms on the number that matters most: what reaches your account.

$48.60
reaches you from a $50 gift on GoFundMe as a certified nonprofit
GoFundMe
$48.25
reaches you from a $50 gift on GivePilot with Stripe
Stripe standard US rate
$46.75
reaches you on Givebutter with tips turned off
Givebutter
$4,500
a 3% platform fee costs on $150,000 a year, before processing
Arithmetic

The three pricing models

ModelHow it chargesExamples
Percentage platformsA share of each gift, plus card processingDonorbox, Givebutter with tips off
Tip-funded platformsFree to the nonprofit; donors are asked for an optional tip at checkoutZeffy, Givebutter with tips on
Flat-plan platformsA fixed subscription; nothing taken from the gift beyond processingGivePilot

One $50 gift, compared

What is taken from a $50 card gift, platform fee plus card processing: GivePilot with the PayPal charity rate $1.49; GivePilot with Stripe $1.75; GoFundMe certified nonprofit $1.40; Donorbox Standard $2.88; Givebutter with tips off $3.25; Zeffy or Givebutter with tips on $0.00, funded by donor tips. GivePilot adds a flat monthly plan after the Free plan.
The fee taken from one gift, before any monthly plan or donor tip.
PlatformPlatform fee on the giftProcessing on a $50 card giftWhat reaches you
GivePilot with StripeNone$1.75 (Stripe’s standard US card rate, 2.9% + 30¢)$48.25
GivePilot with PayPalNone$1.49 (PayPal’s published charity rate, 1.99% + 49¢)$48.51
GoFundMe, certified nonprofitNone$1.40 (2.2% + 30¢)$48.60
Donorbox Standard$1.48 (2.95%)$1.40 (Stripe nonprofit rate, 2.2% + 30¢)$47.12
Givebutter, tips turned off$1.50 (3%)$1.75 (2.9% + 30¢)$46.75
Givebutter, tips turned onNoneCovered by donor or Givebutter$50.00
ZeffyNoneCovered by Zeffy$50.00

US figures from each company’s pricing page on November 13, 2026. GivePilot’s paid plans add a flat $8.99 or $17.99 a month and Donorbox’s paid plans add a subscription; Givebutter and Zeffy ask donors for an optional tip at checkout.

Processing is the one cost nobody avoids: card networks and payment providers charge it on every online payment. What varies is everything on top of it.

A year of giving, compared

Fees compound. Here is what a 3% and a 2.95% platform fee cost on top of processing at three levels of yearly online giving.

Yearly online giving2.95% platform fee3% platform feeNo platform fee
$10,000$295$300$0
$50,000$1,475$1,500$0
$150,000$4,425$4,500$0

Platform fee only; card processing applies in every case.

A flat plan has its own cost, but it does not grow when a campaign takes off. The better your year, the more a flat plan saves.

Where tip-funded platforms fit

Zeffy and Givebutter (with tips on) leave the full gift with you by asking donors for an extra tip at checkout. For many nonprofits that works well. Some prefer a checkout that asks for the gift alone, especially when the box sits on their own website under their own name. GivePilot keeps the checkout focused on the donation.

Lower your processing costs too

StepHow it helps
Ask Stripe for its nonprofit discountRegistered nonprofits in the US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and listed European countries can apply when at least 80% of their volume is tax-deductible donations
Use PayPal’s charity rateConfirmed US charities get a reduced rate of 1.99% plus a fixed fee; see PayPal’s published charity rate
Encourage monthly givingThe rate stays the same, but steady gifts lower the cost of raising each dollar

With GivePilot you connect your own Stripe, PayPal or Square account, so any discount you negotiate with your provider applies to every gift automatically.

What else to compare

Fees are the start. The best nonprofit donation platform also needs monthly giving, campaign tools, automatic receipts and a checkout that works on your website. Read our full comparison of donation platforms for nonprofits for those.

Common questions

Which nonprofit donation platform has no fees?
Zeffy charges nonprofits nothing and is funded by donor tips. GivePilot charges no fee on gifts and costs $8.99 or $17.99 a month after the Free plan’s first five donations.
Can I pass processing fees on to donors?
You can ask donors to cover them. GivePilot has an optional cover the fees tick box on every plan, and the amount a donor covers appears on their receipt. Check your local rules on how the covered amount is receipted.
Why is processing charged even on free platforms?
Card networks and payment providers charge for every online payment. Free platforms either absorb that cost or fund it with donor tips.

Put this on your own site

This is the real GivePilot donation box. Yours takes your colour, your amounts and your name, and pays straight into your Stripe, PayPal or Square account.

Put a donation box on your website today

Set up in a few minutes, connect the payment account you already use and take your first gift before the day is out.