How to start a monthly giving program donors stay in

How to start a monthly giving program: what to ask for, which amounts to offer, what to call it and how to keep donors, with a calculator and name ideas.

November 13, 2026Updated November 16, 202612 min readBy the GivePilot team

A monthly giving program asks supporters for a small gift every month in place of one larger gift now and then. For you, it turns unpredictable donations into income you can plan around. For the donor, it is one decision that keeps helping. This guide covers what to ask for, what to call it, how to launch it in a month and how to keep people in it.

The short versionPut a monthly option where people already give, suggest small amounts tied to an outcome, give the program a name, send a receipt every month, make cancelling easy and tell donors what their gifts did.

What a monthly giving program is

It is a recurring donation with an identity. The recurring part is the payment: a card charged the same amount on the same day each month until the donor stops it. The identity is everything around it: a name, a short promise about what the gifts do, and regular news for the people who joined. A monthly option with no identity still works. A named program with a clear promise works better, because donors join something and stay for it.

Why monthly giving matters

  • Predictable income. You know roughly what next month brings before it starts, which makes rent, salaries and programs easier to plan.
  • More over a year. $20 a month is $240 a year. Many people who would not give $240 at once will give $20 a month.
  • Less asking. One decision keeps the support coming, so your appeals can focus on new donors and special projects.
  • A closer relationship. Someone who hears from you every month, with a receipt and an update, knows your work better than someone who gave once last winter.
What $20 a month adds up to in a year: 10 monthly donors give $2,400, 50 give $12,000 and 100 give $24,000. Donors stay when they get a receipt every month, can cancel easily and hear what their gifts did.
What $20 a month adds up to, and the three habits that keep donors giving.

Work out what it could bring in

Before you launch, set a target you can explain to your board. Start with the monthly donors you think you can sign up in the first month, the average gift, how many new donors you can add each month and how many will stay. Be cautious with the last number: some donors will cancel and some cards will fail.

Calculator

What could monthly giving bring in?

Put in your own numbers. The percentage that stay is your assumption, so try a cautious one.

$9,292
Raised in 12 months
$1,090
Monthly income in month 12
54
Monthly donors in month 12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

Income by month. This is arithmetic on your inputs, before payment processing fees, not a forecast.

Step 1: Make monthly a choice in the box

The easiest monthly program is a toggle. Put a one-time or monthly choice at the top of your donation box, so every donor sees it at the moment they give. In GivePilot this is built in on the Grassroot plan, and the donate button changes to show the amount and “a month” so nobody is surprised by a second charge.

Step 2: Choose monthly-friendly amounts

Monthly amounts are smaller than one-time gifts. Offer three or four, such as $10, $20 and $35, and tie each to an outcome: “$20 a month keeps a family supplied with clean water”. An outcome turns a price into a reason. GivePilot lets you set up to eight preset amounts plus a custom amount.

You will see large charities ask for amounts like $19 a month. The usual reasons are simple: it sits just under a round number, and it works out to about 63 cents a day, which is an easy sentence to say in an appeal. You do not need to copy the number. Pick amounts your own supporters can say yes to without thinking hard, and say what each one does.

Step 3: Give the program a name

A name such as “Friends of the Library” or “Water Keepers” gives monthly donors an identity and gives you something to put on a page, in an email subject and on a thank-you card. Good names are short, say who the members are, and connect to the mission. Avoid names that only describe the payment, like “Recurring Donors”.

Name ideas

Find a name for your program

Check that another organization near you is not already using the name.

Step 4: Write the ask

A monthly ask has three parts: the problem, what a monthly gift does about it, and how easy it is to start and stop. Keep it to a few sentences. For example: “Every month we feed 140 families. $20 a month covers one family’s groceries for a week. Join the Table Keepers today, and change or cancel your gift any time.” Our free donation letter templates give you a structure to start from.

Step 5: Send a receipt every month

Monthly donors need a record of every gift, and a monthly receipt is also a gentle reminder of the good they are doing. GivePilot sends a receipt for the first gift and for every renewal, in your organization’s name, and on Grassroot it can send from your own email address. If you write receipts by hand for other gifts, the free donation receipt template shows what one should contain.

Step 6: Let donors manage their giving

Donors stay longer when leaving is easy, because they trust you. GivePilot gives every donor a portal: they sign in with a one-time code sent to their email, see every gift and cancel a monthly donation themselves. No password, no awkward email to your team.

Step 7: Report back

The biggest reason monthly donors stop is feeling forgotten. Share what their support did: a photo, a number, a short story. One update a month is enough. GivePilot campaigns carry story updates with photos, which you can post from your console in a minute, and a fundraising thermometer shows progress toward a goal on your own site.

A four-week launch plan

  1. Week 1: set it up. Connect your payment provider, turn on the monthly option, choose your amounts and name the program.
  2. Week 2: write it. Draft the ask, a short page about the program and the first three monthly updates so you are never starting from a blank page.
  3. Week 3: ask your closest supporters first. Board members, volunteers and past donors. Ask each one personally. A program with twenty founding members is easier to join than one with none.
  4. Week 4: go public. Add the program to your website and email signature, announce it to your whole list and thank the founding members by name where they agree to it.

Keeping monthly donors

  • Thank them in the first week. A personal note or call after the first gift sets the tone for the whole relationship.
  • Watch for failed payments. Cards expire and get replaced. Stripe can retry a failed payment automatically, so check the retry settings in your Stripe account, and contact the donor kindly when a gift does not go through.
  • Ask for an increase once a year, not more. Tie it to something specific: “$5 more a month would add a second delivery day.”
  • Mark the anniversary. A short message after twelve months, with what a year of their gifts achieved, is the best retention email you will send.
  • Do not hide the exit. A donor who can pause or cancel without a fight is more likely to come back later.

What you need to run it

NeedHow GivePilot handles it
Monthly option in the boxOne-time or monthly toggle on the Grassroot plan
PaymentsMonthly gifts through Stripe, paid into your own account
ReceiptsOne for the first gift and one for every renewal
Donor self-servicePasswordless donor portal with history and cancel
UpdatesCampaign story updates with photos
TrackingMonthly gifts counted on your console overview

GivePilot takes nothing from each gift. Monthly giving is on the Grassroot plan at $17.99 a month; the pricing page has the details. If you are comparing tools first, see our guide to the best donation platforms for nonprofits.

To see how monthly giving, retention and gift size compare across eight causes, read our report on online giving by nonprofit sector.

Launch monthly givingConnect Stripe, move to Grassroot and the monthly option appears in your box. Start free.

Common questions

What is a monthly giving program?
It is a way for supporters to give a set amount automatically every month. Most programs add a name, a clear promise about what the gifts do, and regular updates for members.
How do I build a monthly giving program?
Add a monthly option to your donation form, choose three or four small amounts tied to outcomes, name the program, ask your closest supporters first, then send a receipt and an update every month.
Why do charities ask for $19 a month?
It sits just under a round number and works out to about 63 cents a day, which is easy to say in an appeal. Any small amount tied to a clear outcome can work.
What is a good name for a monthly giving program?
A short name that says who the members are and connects to your mission, such as Water Keepers, Friends of the Library or The Table Circle. Avoid names that only describe the payment.
How much should I ask monthly donors to give?
Offer a few small amounts, such as $10, $20 and $35, with a custom option. Tie each to something specific it pays for.
How do I set up recurring donations on my website?
Use a donation tool with a monthly option in the box. In GivePilot, connect Stripe and choose the Grassroot plan; the one-time or monthly choice appears automatically.
Can donors cancel monthly donations themselves?
Yes. GivePilot’s donor portal lets them sign in with a one-time email code and cancel at any time.
Can monthly donations use PayPal?
In GivePilot, monthly gifts run through Stripe. PayPal and Square handle one-time gifts.

Put this on your own site

This is the real GivePilot donation box. Yours takes your colour, your amounts and your name, and pays straight into your Stripe, PayPal or Square account.

Put a donation box on your website today

Set up in a few minutes, connect the payment account you already use and take your first gift before the day is out.